Poser516,
If this is your first time sealing a blank, spackle is more beginner friendly, in my opinion. You get a much longer working time to work on your squeegee technique when using it, and if it gets thick, you can use more water or Future to thin it, I now use Future. Let it dry completely before you sand, and especially before you laminate. Spackle also leaves a snow white surface, whiter than the foam itself almost, great for aesthetics. Go to your local hardware store/home supply, and get some Dap Fast n’ Final. Thin it some with distilled water or Future floor finish. Go to town. Sand it after it dries (you can’t smell the Future scent anymore when it dries), admire your creation without the EPS divots/dips/voids, and get to airbrushing and/or laminating.
If the spackle feels dry really quickly, beware. Remember the ability of EPS foam to take in fluid. Essentially, the water/Future is being sucked up by the blank through capillary action. You have to wait for this sucked in water to dry. How long is that? I always give it more time than I think it would take. One of the great things about using Future is that the scent it has gives you a sort of barometer on how dry it is. When I can’t smell it anymore, I give it one more day, then I laminate. A lot depends on environmental conditions.
If you know your way around a squeege, epoxy/microballoons is the way to go. It is much stronger (you can feel it if you seal a scrap piece this way vs spackle), and if you lam within 12-24 hours, best glass to foam bond you are going to get. No long wait to dry (spackle can take days to fully dry). Mix the epoxy up, add microballoons 1:1 mixed resin:microballoons ratio by volume. WEAR A PARTICULATE RESPIRATOR when working with microballons. Silicosis is not something you want to brag to your kids about having. You will not need much epoxy, just a few ounces. Add some white pigment to the mix if you care about aesthetics. The mix will feel like pancake batter, and look like marshmallow cream. Spread it on.
If you are not confident in your squeegee abilities, mix up smaller batches and do the board in sections. No problem. Epoxy is forgiving. Watch for drips and thick spots, they are hard to sand down without cutting through the seal into adjacent foam (negating the seal step) if you spot them after cure.
Both methods work well. Since you want a heavy board anyway, it will probably have plenty of cloth; if I were you, I would spackle. It looks good and works. If I want a board to look pretty, I spackle. If you want the strongest, and at the same time, lightest board you can get (best strength to weight ratio), epoxy and microballoons.
But, if you want to prove this to yourself, get your offcuts/scraps and spackle one and epoxy/micro the other. compare/contrast, laminate the pieces w/ scrap glass, break/tear the glass off the pieces after cure, see which one you like best, and let us know how it went…
Above all, RELAX. Your board will come out well.
JSS