hi Chris !
did you get , and read , the private message I sent you ?
Some of those questions , when answered , ‘should’ give us / you an idea what to modify ?
Also , did you read the ‘ideal paddling and volume’ thread , too ?
[There are some interesting thoughts there , for sure , also , on thickness , paddling styles , rocker …]
Depending on the waves you want to surf regularly , your paddling style , and HOW you [want to] surf , too .
with fish[es?] …
Try a board , if a friend has one , that is thinner .
Try a board , ditto, that is narrower .
Try shorter boards ,
longer boards ,
more rockered boards ,
flatter boards …
EXPERIMENT !
… test ride as much different [fish] stuff [and fins / keel templates] as you can , mate , so you can hopefully find what works best for YOU , in YOUR waves…
I could say what I like in my waves in fishes I have tried , and what I haven’t enjoyed …that would be my personal preference , and to some extent , my experience . And , it would be for the waves I ride here in Perth , West Oz…which may be WAAAY different to yours .
As an example , I like a bit of nose rocker in my fish . And a more pulled in swallowtail . And a shallower "butt crack" [if you MUST call it that ?!] . And keels pointed towards the nose . And a flat bottom . And hard rails in the tail , to maybe at least 8" forward of the leading edge of the keels .
…These are things I have found to work well here , for me , for my ‘style’ of surfing .
Oh , and I also like removeable fins [you may have noticed ?!] , so I can change the setup to a twin FIN , instead of keels , or a quad fin setup , or a single fin … you get the idea, I’m sure !
the fish “purists” are probably covering their ears and eyes right about now , but the ‘traditional’ fish I have ridden I didn’t like …it was difficult making it work in shifty beachbreak surf [for me , at least].
okay , I hope this helps , Chris !
cheers mate ,
ben
p.s. - do you have any photos / a description of the sort of waves that you will be riding say 80 % of the time on your fish ? cheers , that would help !