hi mate
I'm sure you like a challenge !
[as evidenced by your first board where you basically made your own blank out of ??? who knows WHAT ?]
and I would be the LAST one on 'Swaylocks' to discourage experimenting , and thinking outside of the 'box'
[ ...here it comes....]
BUT !
.... for the waves you ride , for a total of a couple of years of surfing experience , from shaping one surfboard....
ask yourself , perhaps ,
WHY ?
why complicate things ?
why curved or twisted fins ?
why some funky , hard to make fin ?
why am I making it difficult for myself ?
WILL this be the best performing board , and fin setup , for my setup [beach , and the type of waves I will be surfing] , 98 % of the time ?
if I am not going to ENJOY this setup , and have more FUN surfing , as a result ....WHY do it ??
Here's a bit of background on me , if this will clarify things a bit [I hope] .....
I haven't always experimented with "different" fins , and "different " boards .
for the first [probably ] 25 years of my surfing life , I rode 'conservative ' boards , and fins . Tried to get an idea of what design features [eg: shape , outline , rocker , thickness , bottoms ] did for a board. And what "normal" fins did ...how they performed , their good and their bad points.
It has really only been since fin systems [fcs ...? 1990s?] , that I have started to play around with fin design , 'moveability' , different NUMBERS of fins , and boards . [ In fact , since 1985 , I have only ever shaped 17 boards , so I would in no way consider myself a shaper , or an expert on THAT ! At least SIX of those were before I had a John Carper shaping and glassing video , to give me a bit of a clue exactly what I needed to do ...and , I only heard about / joined 'Swaylocks' , as recently as 2004 ['chipfish61' days] ]
If I had done this [making different and difficult fins , and boards] too much in my 'formative' surfing years , it would have confused me , not done my surfing any good , and I probably would have become discouraged . [? And maybe even given it away for a while ? at some stage over the last 41 years since I first had a fibreglass board ....god forbid !]
I guess all I'm saying , to summarise in a short sentence , is ...
...simplify things , perhaps ?
learn the basics ...basic board designs , features ...what they do .
....Likewise , with fins ! ....
If we have too much going on with the board , then mate that with too much going on with the fins , without having some sort of 'baseline' reference to work from ...
then , HOW will we know WHAT is doing WHAT ? [.... in terms of our board , our fin[s] setup , ourselves [user shortcomings , I guess I would call it , to be diplomatic]
wow , this has been probably the longest written post I have made , for a while !
[ but it's something I feel passionate about , is why !]
Of course , having written all this , I understand and accept that you can go ahead and ignore everything I and others have written here at 'Swaylock's , over the years. [many do ! ...it's a free world , and we have freedom of CHOICE , of course , in this day and age . Thankfuklly ].
..... I know I do the same , when it is stuff I disagree with , or that doesn't work for me , design-wise and surfing-wise . ( After all, you know what they say about 'arguing on the internet " ?? ....or arguing , in general , in REAL life .... :) )
I only give you this 'advice' , for what it is 'worth' [?!] ,
.....because I want you to enjoy your surfing , on the most functional [fun , to ride ! ] board you can make , with fins that are going to HELP you do that [rather than hinder] !
maybe try your fairly tricky [for a second board, that is !] board design [if you must be tricky ?! ha !] with simple , 'conservative' fin designs first , so you get an idea of what the BOARD is doing .
Then , maybe later down the track , when you have um "mastered" your board [?] ...
.....THEN ... maybe you can try some tricky , funky fins [if you really feel you "must" [?] ]
WHY ?
.... because you will by then hopefully have established some kind of 'performance baseline' to work off , in terms of your board's 'feel' , and what you know it / you can do on a wave together.
of course , if this is all too " serious" / 'intense' , and you "just wanna have FUN " , THAT is good , too ...nothing wrong with THAT , in life !!
just don't 'throw the baby out with the bathwater' , so to speak , is the 'gist' of what I am trying to say , regarding maybe give all these words some consideration ... [like I say , I am not one for writing long wordy posts , unless it is some 'issue' I feel passionately about ...and this , obviously , is one of them ....the 'K.I.S.S. * Principle' WORKS ! well for me , anyway !]
[ I enjoy our "off air" 'chats' ... please keep 'em up , matey !]
cheers Col !
ben
* " K.I.S.S. "
that's [HERE , at least !]...
" keep it SIMPLE , surfer !"