What is so sacred about "Sacred Craft" this year?

“WHY: Because surfboards are more than a commodity and making surfboards is more than a process-- they are both PASSIONS… and they are both SACRED CRAFTs!”

The above statement is part of the advertisement the producers of the Sacred Craft surfboard show are putting on in a few months.

I am prepared to take some heat for this write up, but with all the teary eyed accolades for this show and it’s original stated purpose, I wanted to write a view to consider.

First I want to say that I have nothing against Scott and the others that are putting this event on. In fact, I like them and appreciate their many efforts in certain areas. Nor am I advocating a boycott or saying that Asian made or mass produced machined boards do not have their place. I am advocating that those who speak up about there being a difference in their craft and what you find coming out of Asia or off machines, consider that they are lining up with and helping to make equal the very folks they claim they want to separate their craft from.

It was my understanding that this event was an event to draw a line of distinction between the local and custom surfboard builders and the mass produced and overseas manufactures. I was always under the impression that though this event was certainly not anti mass production or anti Asian manufacture. It was supposed to be a pro custom manufacture and designed to help the domestic craftsmen?

I think everyone knows that certain things can take a life of their own and when something is a success, the temptation or even the heavy pull to follow it up with a bigger or greater success is almost unbearable. Not that there is anything at all wrong with success or attempting to grow that success. My contention with what I see this year, is that the event includes the very people who have purposely blurred the lines with advertisement and magazine hype with what a hand crafted custom shape (or sacred craft) actually is.

From what I see, this years event it is little more than a glorified trade show for the consumer. Compete with the rags manufactures, their representative lobby, and the Asian mass manufactures. The word sacred in definition is something worthy of worship, or a type of devotion. I get that it’s supposed to be for the surfboard itself, but what exactly is sacred about a mass produced commodity or a show helping to promote clothing, wetsuits and other gadgets as much as the surfboard??

The original draw of this show was that you would be able to show up and see unique craft and craftsmen apart from the hordes of hyped junk found in your average trade expo. That is was going to be a special place of reverence for those who had created this entire industry. Those who have never received the bulk of the money or even the proper credit. It was my understanding that this show was for them.

Leave it to the big money guys to make their presence known and gobble up the booths with their hype. They know how to jump on someone’s good idea and milk it for all it’s worth, because contrary to popular belief, the big guys are not the ones who created the unique atmosphere and draw to the sport of surfing. That was done by a few true pioneer craftsmen and a few unique individual surfers with talent and charisma.

Yes…some of the board builders have benefited from their craft and become rich. Some have even had their chances to become rich and messed them up and yet others never wanted to become rich or be measured by that standard, but Looking back at the above statement where the author states surfboards are MORE than a commodity.

I think it’s clear that the true statement of the ad is… surfboards actually are only a commodity, but it’s important for them to remain cool in the eyes of those that buy them and the commodity side must be downplayed for that to happen.

So the word “sacred” is added to give the impression that all the boards at this show are of the craftsman side rather than the commodity side.

My personal opinion is when you mix the mass produced stuff that exist for the sole purpose of making money with the art created by individuals you not only send a mixed message but participate in a fabrication.

If it’s all about monetary success or about being seen by others in the industry as a player, then why call it Sacred Craft? The literal interpretation of Sacred craft would be….something worthy of devotion, made by hand.

Perhaps it should be renamed Consumer Surf Expo and invitations need to go out to the jet ski manufactures, wake board manufactures, skateboard manufactures, resort wear manufactures and the rest? Just like the other trade shows.

A trade show by any other name is still a trade show. Hype is still greatly exaggerated publicity, and mass produced surfboards are surfboards that you can ride, but craft they are not and I doubt many attending the show would call them sacred.

I certainly wouldn’t taint something called sacred craft with a magazine promotion or rag peddlers still attempting to create the fairy tales or invent the latest fabricated surfer look. Riding on the backs of those who truly did create the fun we all have being out there on the ocean.

Doing the research on design and then creating a surfboard from start to finish by hand is truly a craft. A craft that many practice, but few become masters. Those masters that are with us and those yet to come do deserve to be called craftsmen and the boards they produce to some may in fact become sacred, but this show labeled Sacred Craft is in my opinion a misnomer.

Solo, if there is any truth to what you said then I will need to say bravo.

So…

BRAVO!

Last year Scott offered up an invitation for a free Swaylocks demo time slot. There weren’t any takers but I thought it was a nice gesture. I said then that I thought his heart was in the right place on all this and still do.

Any idea what’s involved setting up an event like that? I’m sure at times he feels like he has a tiger by the tail. The effort he puts in to coordinating so many companies in such a venue must be mind boggling.

In a facility that big, there is probably quite a tab to cover. Convention Halls or whatever you call that facility charge a lot of money. If in an attempt to cover costs he puts out offers to the industry for paid spaces, what’s he supposed to do… “Sorry, you make boards in a Chinese factory… can’t let you participate.” or “Sorry, your business made over $250,000 last year. Can’t let you participate either.” “T-shirts? No they’re on our prohibited list.” ???

Maybe toasting the guy for a good effort at enlightening the consumer is more in order?

My .02 – Way to go Scott. Hope it goes off even better than last year!

Quote:

Last year Scott offered up an invitation for a free Swaylocks demo time slot. There weren’t any takers but I thought it was a nice gesture. I said then that I thought his heart was in the right place on all this and still do.

I think you missed the point of my thread. Already delt with the fact that Scott had his heart in the right place, but that in my opinion…it’s misnamed and that the sucess of the first turned it from a cool happening with a good idea to a full blown business proposition. Last year the hook was baited and this year the big boys and others wanting to capitalize as usual on the craftsmen that make this sport unique stood in line to get their cut.

This year…the temption for a larger haul was too great. Nothing wrong with a sucessful business proposition. I already stated that in the article, but calling it a Sacred Craft show is in my opinion misnaming the show and falling into the category of hype. Likely by accident. I think the show have still be equally as sucessful and stayed more with what I was told the original spirit was with a bit of patience and without the typical expo type crew.

Also…my point is not mostly directed at Scott BTW. It’s directed somewhat at those folk who gripe about the Asian production and machined massed produced commodity boards and how the public doesn’t get informed on the difference and then show up along side them at a show named for the master craftsmen. I have spoken to Scott…I think he is a good guy. I do think his heart is in the right place and I still think the show needs to be renamed because it no longer resembles a show of Sacred Craft given the list I have seen on their site.

Again…I made sure to point out that this was not an anti Asian manufacture or machine mass produced board manufacture thread. Those companies serve their purpose and have their place…but when surfers think of sacred craft…they don’t think of those board. I don’t think some of the master craftsmen find what they produce to be commodities either.

Quote:

In a facility that big, there is probably quite a tab to cover. Convention Halls or whatever you call that facility charge a lot of money. If in an attempt to cover costs he puts out offers to the industry for paid spaces, what’s he supposed to do… “Sorry, you make boards in a Chinese factory… can’t let you participate.” or “Sorry, your business made over $250,000 last year. Can’t let you participate either.” “T-shirts? No they’re on our prohibited list.” ???

Who said there needed to be a bigger facility? Was the orginal purpose to make alot of money or pay a tribute to Sacred Craft? I suspect this year was sold out last year before lasted years show was closed, which is why the temptation to grow it big quick rather than gradual was taken. Yes to two of your questions. The chinese factories should have been told that they do not fit the criteria unless they could produce one Master shaper who designed his own surfboards through R and D, produced his designs and could show similar craftsmanship as some of those this show was originally set to honor. I don’t recall mentioning how much any business made as a criteria either so as long as the surfboard manufature fit the description of domestic boardbuilder or master craftsman as hinted at by Sacred’s own advertisement last year…their income shouldn’t have anything to do with it. On Tee shirt company…yes…I would exclude clothing companies and kept the show small and core had I used a name like Sacred craft. I would have kept to what my show was billed as and allowed for a slower, but more true to name growth. I think that would have been something way more special. As it is…how is it much different than ASR for the public or the Surf Expo for the public?

Quote:

Maybe toasting the guy for a good effort at enlightening the consumer is more in order?

My .02 – Way to go Scott. Hope it goes off even better than last year!

I do toast Scott for an exellent marketing effort and from what I have heard running an exellent trade show of sorts, but again…I just think he misnamed it for the reasons I mentioned. I think some of the biggest critics of the chinese manufactures and mass production of surfboards that attend the show should either quit saying there is a distinction in what they do and the commodity manufatures do or pull out of the show. If they want to be honest about their claims. If it’s all about advertisment and making money…nothing wrong with that either, but just don’t call it sacred anymore.

Quote:

Any idea what’s involved setting up an event like that? I’m sure at times he feels like he has a tiger by the tail. The effort he puts in to coordinating so many companies in such a venue must be mind boggling.

Yes…I have set up a few in my time. I helped set up one where Kelly Slater showed up and passed out trophies for local amateur contest season. 2500 folks showed up. It came complete with photographs and a gallery film. Did a few more also for another industry.

There is zero vitrol in my thread. Not a single bit.

Last year I ponied up the hundreds of dollars for my very own 100 sq.ft. booth next to a double wide pop-out SUP booth and on the other side a San Diego based mass “producer”…

I too thought an event called the Sacred Craft Expo would be something different than just another trade show, you know with words like “Sacred” and “Craft”…But 96.74% of all the people coming though the door just had the Trade Show walk the aisles and ask “got any stickers” mentality…

To most of them, acid splash a computer shaped board and it’s extra special…“Whoa duuude…!!!..”…Construct it different, as in really different, as a few of us did and it’s given the 2.5 second overlook, then onto something familiar…Something the masses can relate to… Something they have seen before in the magazines…Something like a Rusty, or a CI or a (insert you favorite clothing label, oops, surfboard label here)…They were there too in their five wide booths…Extra sacred…

Don’t blame the masses for reacting that way, most of what they know is all driven by the Surf Media…The Surf Media is driven by who pays them money to advertise with them…A full circle loop…As it always has been…Business…Could be any product…But our flavor is surfing…

Even though Scott had / has the right motivation, he can’t check the intent of those who display…Some come to share new designs, others are there simply to move “product” and empty a warehouse…Business…

Perhaps my filters are skewed because I’m coming from a non- surf town, and I haven’t swallowed the hook…

Needless to say, but I’m not going back…There’s more of interest here…

And way more soul…

I call Swaylock’s Sacred…

Paul

Everyone should make their own boards…

The Asian manufacturers where there last year too. Nine Fish, Boardworks, Firewire, Placebo to name a few. Yeah, I think the name is kinda hokey. I guess that’s just marketing. Consumer Surfboard Expo would be fine.

Being at the resent ASR Show, SC is a nice thing to look forward to. I go there for the board porn aspect of the show. Kinda like going to a custom car show.

If the main purpose of the show is to create interest in the product and thus hopefully generate more sales, I think the date of the show is all wrong. It should be held in the Spring which is right before the time of year that most surfboards are bought and sold- Summer.

Solo,

I think the whole concept of the Sacred Craft show is fantastic, regardless of how large the event gets. The focus is on the boards, as opposed to events like Surf Expo, which are primarily about the clothes and other soft goods. Events like the shape-off they had last year exposes more people to hand-shaped surfboards and underscores that what a shaper does is indeed ‘sacred.’ Having the opportunity for a shaper to have more people exposed to their handiwork is a good thing. Why does it matter if the pop-outs and mass produced boards are side-by-side with hand-shaped boards? If you are confident that hand-crafted boards are higher quality than the mass produced crap, then seeing the boards displayed in the same place will only reinforce that position. Events like this will expose more people to the magic of hand-shaped surfboards regardless of whether pop-outs are there.

Why is it when somthing is successful or gets big we have to start throwing stones at it?

“Needless to say, but I’m not going back…”

Too bad. The thing I liked about the “original” one was that it had at its roots the idea of giving small guys and “alternative” board builders a chance to show their stuff. That was why I went and for me was neat to see different stuff. I felt that a lot of people went for the same reason. Hopefully this won’t change. I am making one of my 8’ Six shooter “Squish” to display, so there will be something different. For me it would not be as interesting to drive to Del Mar to see the same Popouts that I can see from my chair at the beach.

Even though I am a tadpole in this pond, I can definetly see both sides of the argument.

I really wanted to go last year but turned out I had other things that took priority that weekend.

My reasons for going this year is so that I can meet some of the greats and soon to great hand shapers.

Just being exposed more to you all that will be there is enough for me to show up.

Hope to run into some of you there, even though i probably won’t realize it if I do.

Chris Harvey

Quote:

Solo,

I think the whole concept of the Sacred Craft show is fantastic, regardless of how large the event gets. The focus is on the boards, as opposed to events like Surf Expo, which are primarily about the clothes and other soft goods. Events like the shape-off they had last year exposes more people to hand-shaped surfboards and underscores that what a shaper does is indeed ‘sacred.’ Having the opportunity for a shaper to have more people exposed to their handiwork is a good thing. Why does it matter if the pop-outs and mass produced boards are side-by-side with hand-shaped boards? If you are confident that hand-crafted boards are higher quality than the mass produced crap, then seeing the boards displayed in the same place will only reinforce that position. Events like this will expose more people to the magic of hand-shaped surfboards regardless of whether pop-outs are there.

Why is it when somthing is successful or gets big we have to start throwing stones at it?

It’s not a cut on Asian as you say…" crap" It’s not about mass produced boards and how they relate to hand shaped surfboards. The name is a misnomer, the advertising is false. I believe the intentions are good ( especially given how affordable it is), but the advertisment is wrong.

To some of us that have made our living from this sport and learned to sell things we believe in and promote the part of our industry that is unique and the personalities that have helped make this sport interesting…it’s hard to see yet another outing of the same old stuff sold as something hardcore and special. When I see the major surf magazines there and some of the rag manufactures lobby there…it tells me that it’s just another business idea with an appealing catch line.

The idea of the show as it was orginally sold to us was to spotlight on craftsmen. Hence the name…Sacred Craft. Words mean things. They convey a message. A craft is something built by hand, by a craftsman. Sacred is something worthy of reverence. The lead line in the ad says…Surfboards are more than a commodity. I think the true craftsmen of this sport would take issue with something calling what they create as a commidity. Not that there is anything wrong with a commodity either or an Asian manufatured board that is honest about what it is. But a commodity is not usually associated with a craft. That is simple a fact, unless we plan on redefining certain terms.

There is nothing wrong with catchy advertisement. I love some of the stuff the commodity driven companies come up with from time to time, but selling something as promoting craft and then allowing the lines to be blurred sends a mixed message. Some of those craftsmen, (which is really as much what my thread about as the shows name) which go on about not supporting handcrafted boards or not telling the public the difference between them and then show up at a show which blurrs those lines a bit should probably re think their positions on that. BTW: I find nothing magical about hand shaping, but handshaping is a craft produced by " a " craftsman. Having boards made in a mass production line of sorts is just not.

Here is some more of the advertising:

"SACRED CRAFT - The Consumer Surfboard Expo is bringing together all of us who love surfboards --and all things surfboard-- under one roof for a weekend long surfboard extravaganza in Del Mar. A large exposition hall at the Del Mar Fairgrounds filled with the objects of our desire! If it has to do with the SURFBOARD it will be at SACRED CRAFT - The Consumer Surfboard Expo.

WHY?

Because it dawned on us that the surfboard makers needed a way to market their wares, and the surfer needed a place they could go to talk surfboard design with the people that make them, rather than some 17-year-old shop rat that doesn’t know…shoestrings. Most of you remember a time when you could go into a surfshop and talk to a shaper. They’re still out there, thank God, but sadly they are a dying breed. "

See they even call the show a cosumer expo. Sacred Craft has just become a catch title.

Let me ask you a question: What is a person going to learn from some of these surfboard " makers" as opposed to shapers? From the popout manufactures they are going to learn pretty much what they have already been marketed by magazines and surf shops. From Asian manufactures they will probably learn that the quality on some of them is every bit as good as local or domestic manufacutured board sold in most surf shops. How are the shapers going to compete head to head under the same roof with the fancy booths and advertising dollars that some of these folks have? Do you believe the consumers are going to gravitate towards any of the smaller less known shapers just because they are there?

I can tell you the answer is absolutely no. Why? Because this show likely doesn’t have anymore surfboards than the large expos and I have seen the small shapers in many of those waste their money and not get very much out of the show because the larger manufactures have more ability to draw in customers. Thats business.

Not only that…now the surfboard craftmen are also going to have to compete with Wetsuit manufactures, clothing manufactures and lobby groups all there to gain attention for themselves also.

What has happened is the business side has had to take prominence over the craftsmen. Craftsmen whose being there is the draw of this show in the first place.

To me…to emphasize craftmanship. A show should be filled with only craftsmen and then let the customer really go over some of these lesser known or forgotten craftsmen. If it’s small…choose a smaller place to hold it. If it grows, which I think it would anyway…then add it. After awhile you have all the craftsmen there in one place in a truly special event. Free from magazine hype, free from rags salesmen and free from lobby groups whose job is to promote big industry. Needless to say…I consider all big business the enemy of the small guy.

On my part…this is certainly not throwing stones at Scott or his show. It’s about truth and constructive criticism.

As always…I appreciate your input BMG. Scott and I have had some conversations. He knows I believe him to have his heart in the right place, I like him and consider myself a supporter not a detrator…but I think honest evaluation and criticism is a good thing. Not a negative.

Solosurfer

I understand your dissapointment.

but my opinion is that you must go and be present and accounted for.

as so should as many of us other hand shapers, glasser’s and or sanders or panters and polishers

so as “they” will be there , so shall “we”.

Quote:

Solosurfer

I understand your dissapointment.

but my opinion is that you must go and be present and accounted for.

as so should as many of us other hand shapers, glasser’s and or sanders or panters and polishers

so as “they” will be there , so shall “we”.

I respect your view and all the views presented here whether they agree or disagree. This is like a family hashing out something they all want to see work. Not attacking an enemy.

I like the original concept. I can’t stand surf expos because they are more about impressing your competitors or being seen as a player as they are about conveying valid points to consumers or retailers. I can prove it as I have just gotten my Surf Expo magazine and one of the comments from one of the key manfuatures states…we go to the surf expo to gain the respect of our peers.

The only people that are imortant to me in my business are my customers and those who produce my products. The competitors opinions don’t matter a single iota.

I must emphasize…This is not a call to boycott.

Paul Jensen, Andrew my rep and I talked it over, I had 2 booths reserved, the outlay was essentially 100.00$ per board.

With the prospect of selling maybe one to two boards, the real place to express ones self is in this medium, the word of mouth goes so much further, testimonials are read by billions, satisfied clients post pictures of their purchases.

San Diego is my stomping grounds, but once again it would be a geographic phenomenon and not wide spread exposure.

I feel that a chance at being in my shaping room and wood working area is a far greater experience at being exposed to a Sacred Craft.

Last year I was so stoked to be included in the shape off, but it turned into a torture experience with the absolute piece of turd blank I got and the hour and a half to do what should have been allotted at least 3 hours to do.

When I shape, it is finished when it is right, not at the ding off a bell.

All of the shapers got the same shake as me, so I’m not calling poop on anything but the crappy blank that refused to be planed in any way concerned normal

I went last year. There was some cool stuff. I bought a bar of petro free wax for a dollar. It actually ended up being pretty good. I marveled at the see through cardboard surfboard. I forget who it was, but someone was displaying a beautiful chambered redwood beast that looked like it was 12 feet long. I remember feeling a little overwhelmed by how crowded it was, while I was trying to push a baby stroller down through the booths. Suddenly, I looked over and saw a couple of Paul Jensen surfboards leaning against a wall. There was only one guy hanging out in the booth, and I thought “wow! that must be Paul.” I introduced myself, and had a nice conversation with him. A very down to Earth guy. It was definitely the highlight of the day for me.

On the positive side of the Sacred Craft equation is being able to get to meet some Swaylock’s folks and guys like Jim Phillips…

Let me re-phrase that, since there’s no one else like him…I met the one and only Jim Phillips…

It was my pleasure…

Paul

I didn’t go last year so I’m gonna go this year. In fact, I’m giving a 45 minute presentation on the role of the backyarder through the history of surfboard crafting and the role Swaylock’s has had on the backyarder. If I have any time left over, I’ll show everyone how to measure rocker…

If you’re not part of the solution then maybe you are part of the problem.

Looking forward to seeing everyone the following weekend at Big Sur…(Oct 17-20)

Solo…

you are invited…send your $25 to John Mellor or show up early to get a spot in the main campground…

…I paid for two spots so send me a PM and I’ll get you a “BRO DEAL”…

Share the stoke!

Stingray

Yep, did it last year. The name is terrible although we got to make a sign saying ‘Sacred Consumer Specials’ and made Scared Craftsmen out of our badges. It really is just another tradeshow, but at least there’s some actual surfboards at it and Bassy really has his heart in the right place. If you can get to it, I’d say it’s totally worth the 5 bucks or so to walk around and look at the nice boards, to say nothing of the deals that could be had if you were in the market for new foam. There were a fair degree of popouts there last year, and lots of ‘Damn, fish/quads/resintints/whatever is big right now, we should do one’, but some really nice stuff as well and I met the one and only Paul Jensen. Most of the exhibitors I met were really cool actually, and all loved talking about boards. One of the designs we had was mercilessly ripped off by several shapers within weeks of the show which I find sort of funny. If the Chinese do a knockoff of something people are in tears, but let some one who hangs with the right crowd do essentially the same thing and it’s OK? Ask Wayne Lynch why he dealt with SurfTech and he’ll tell you he figured he may as well because the ****s out there were going to him rip off anyway, so he may as well do it to himself and get paid. I won’t be an exhibitor this year as I figure if they want to rip off the new stuff, let them at least buy one to do it. That said, I wish the show and all who sail with it well. Nothing could be as horrible as the stand up paddle for skateboards that was being pimped at the ASR.

Quote:

Nothing could be as horrible as the stand up paddle for skateboards that was being pimped at the ASR.

Ha Ha Ha…I about busted my gut when I saw a picture of that thing…but thats trade shows. Jim hit it on the head for me…taking a trip and showing up at his factory to talk board design or reading one of his contributions here is way more informative and meaningful to me personally. Tradeshows and to some degree surf shops have mostly become places to hang out, waste time and for customers to see if they can get a board at a discount or free handouts.

I enjoy talking board design with my customers and those who are truly interested in what I am into. It’s one of my passions in life, but having to drown out the white noise at tradeshows to actually get to the craftsmen who matter has never been my favorite thing. Not only that…when you do get to them you usually have to wait behind the surf talker wanting to know if the shaper’s board can handle his cutback.

It’s interesting to read comments from all the craftsmen that I had hoped to see this year

say that they won’t be there after their experience last year.

Does this mean that they’ve made more room for Firetech and accelerated the decline of

the show?

Should the builders have pushed the organizers harder for something truer to the stated

intention of the show? Or is it just a lost cause?