As a PADI Rescue Diver I’ve had a few “opportunities” to try out their training (it works!) Here’s two:
Spring of '07 - Kayaking about 1 mile off, between County Line and Leo Carrillo. Typical early spring conditions - NW wind about 10-15kts, water about 51-54f. While I was fishing, I watched a kite boarder who seemed to be struggling. His kite would go down, then he’d pop it up, only to go down again. After appx, 30 minutes, his kite went down and didn’t come up again. After 5 minutes. I decided to paddle over and make sure he was OK.
I stopped about 10ft from him and asked if he was OK while observing him (per training). He was VERY pale, hyperventilating slightly, had a blank expression, and didn’t respond to my questions. I figured (based on his “soak time” and appearance) that he was hypothermic, and panicked. Then he reacted as I’d been warned about - he lunged towards me and started blindly thrashing and “climbing the invisible ladder” as someone mentioned earlier in the thread. I used my paddle to fend him off and calmly informed him that he would have to settle down to get in my boat, or I would throw him a line and tow him in. After a few seconds he did calm down, we got him and his kite rig in the boat, and paddled to shore until a lifeguard met us and took over.
(BTW - the Lifeguard told me that they don’t deal with their rigs - they just cut them free)
The other was a spearfisherman who kicked out past another surfer & I on a fairly heavy day (1.5 to DOH waves). The other surfer & I laughed about it, thinking that the visibility would be terrible (usually 10ft on a GOOD day at this spot). 20 minutes later, he passed us again on his way in. Somewhere in the impact zone, he must have panicked and screamed the magic word (HELP!!). I looked at the other guy and said “Let’s go! I’m a PADI rescue diver.” He asked how he could help, I asked if he’d take my board when I got to the diver, then stay close in case I needed him. As we approached him, I yelled out “Diver, are you OK?” - He screamed “HEEEELLLLPP!!!” Guess not… So I instructed him to ditch his weight belt and told him that I am a rescue diver and that he was going to be OK. That seemed to calm him a bit.
When I got to him I found that he HADN’T ditch his weights, or his gun, and we were standing on the bottom in chest deep water. I took his weight belt off (and STUPIDLY put it over one of my own shoulders!), got an arm under his armpits from behind, and told him we were going to roll up on the beach with the next wave. The next wave rolled us up just like I said it would. When we got to the dry sand, I hung around for a couple minutes to see that he was OK. Other than a little fright and embarrassment, he was fine.
The main difference in the two rescues was the victims - the first one would have probably capsized my boat and tried to climb over me if I hadn’t kept a safe distance and fended him off awhile I waited for him to calm (or tire) - also, we were way out past the surfline in calm water with a 12’6" Ocean Kayak, so I had more time (and water, food & beer!).
The second was responding (though not obeying) and cooperative. Since we were in the surfline and VERY close to shore, I acted a bit quicker.