Alternative Vacuum Bagging Methods

Ive got a few ideas brewing about laminating my solid paulownia project. Im trying to avoid using big 20+ inch clamps as they are expensive and tricky to use on the next part of my project - glueing the shaped blank back together after chambering (clamping the rounded rails seems to be the tricky part). Ive tried using old bicycle tubes but they dont seem to give enough pressure to connect the timber perfectly as its not completely straight.

anyway I thought vacumm bagging would be a good way to do the glue up.

Ive used the Roarockit hand pump system with building skateboards before and it worked quite well. With a good seal, the vacuum would easily hold for hours at a time. My bag has since lots its perfect seal and i thought the next logical progression would be to get a pump which would keep the vacuum continuous.

then i saw www.bagbutton.com.au and it got me thinking.

has anyone tried anything like this? I would be keen to hear if it has worked. it seems so simple.

a couple of thoughts/questions -

would the pressure from a thinner garbage-like bag be as much as that of a thicker nylon tubing type bag? Im thinking yes it would as long as the vacuum is the same in both cases.

would a thicker bag have less leaks?

given that Ive been able to easily laminate and bend three pieces of 2mm bamboo ply in a hand pumped Roarockit bag that has no continuous vacuum, it seems as though it would be possible to use this technique on a surfboard.

and another thought i had at the supermarket picking up a vacuum sealed pizza, what about creating a perfect vacuum seal like they do on all of these food products? Surely it would be possible to do it on a surfboard?

any ideas on the tools/heat seal methd used to seal a bag permanantly and remove the air at the same time?

would a thicker bag work “better”? The only quality of a bag is that it doesn’t leak. To the extent that a thicker bag might be more durable, then a thicker bag is better, until it leaks. I think transparency would be a plus, too.

The only concern about how much pressure is exerted is how much vacuum you pull. Making paths inside the bag for any air pockets to be sucked down is mandatory.

I suspect the supermarket bags such as for bacon, etc. are drawn down with a “wand” or suction line that is withdrawn from inside the bag, as the bag is sealed at its edges by heat (perhaps using microwave energy). Heat sealers are not uncommon household items, though their day, if they had one, was probably several years ago.

Don’t go fancy, just get something that works. See elsewhere in the archives, there seems to be a limit how much vacuum you want to pull.

As for putting your chambered wood back together, alignment is critical. Clamping pressure is not. You just want to stick the sticks back together enough to fine shape, and for that I’d think it needs to be out in the open where you can see it and adjust alignment. I read that you want to do two adjacent sticks at a time, and I’d think you want to start from the center and work outward. The strength comes from glassing, and for a wood board, I don’t see why you’d want the trouble of vacuum bagging. just a plain 'ol two-on-the-top, one-on-the-bottom lam.

fantastic idea!

just bought a dozen so we’ll see

love to take this with me traveling with a portable hand pump

But a great way to put on skins and rail bands without electricity

with this and my battery powered planer,drywall saw and a bottle of 5 min epoxy or gorilla glue and I can make a wood skinned EPS composite anywhere in the world (New Guinea?)

Quote:

Vacuum cleaners only pull about 5 inches. Not really a good pull , adaquate sometimes but not really the right tool.

This is more what you need. Not that pricy if your serious.

http://www.fiberglasssupply.com/Product_Catalog/Vacuum_Bagging/vacuum_bagging.html

thanks for the replies.

as for the 5 inches, maybe something like this will work better - http://www.pump-n-seal.com/comparison.htm ( a hand pump that pulls 28Hg!!! for only $25)

check out the instructional video, its classic. I think your comment honolulu about household vacumm sealers having had their day several years ago is expresed well in this video!!

i just ordered a bag button anyway as i figured i would use it around the house even if it doesnt work for surfboards.

Ive been googling a bit of info on how to seal bags airtight (which is critical if you dont have a continuous vacuum). So far Im thinking the best way would be to get my project in a PE bag, heat seal it so there are no leaks and then use something like the pump’n’seal to get the air out and pull a vac.

Im not opposed to using a proper vacuum pump as it is obviously a proven method, but i just keep thinking that there could be a simpler and cheaper way.

anyway, im excited by these ideas so ill be having a crack at them. Ill let you know how they go.

dont try an reinvent the wheel

thanks for the encouragement paul.

lol sorry :slight_smile:

na what imeant was you can bet that anything anyone suggests on sways about baging that there 100 guys that have tried as version of it

pretty soon i think greg will be selling cores for bagging

and even a stringerless marko is perfect

just add on the pvc stringers yourself in the method i suggest in the thread

straight pvc strips thermoformed with a heatgun

understood. im not trying to reinvent a process that obviously works very well.

im just looking at different ways that may or may not work. seems to be what this forum is all about.

in all my searching through the archives i havent found anyone who has tried using methods like these.

if it has been done, id love to know. It would save me a lot of time messing around!

hey bro youll have enough challenges and fun setting things up

i used the storage bags for fin layups and a vacuum cleaner

alll sorts of stuff

i think i even posted the pics here

works okay for small layups in carbon

but that before i discovered mastic

and a 20 dollar diapraghm pump

perhaps get a sheet of stiff plastic and make a rocker table and use a sheet of baggingfilm and stick it straight down to the stiff plastic

okay so you glue everything and tape it all in place and put the wholelot in the bag

if you use elmers or tightbond its would be quick bag time maybe an hour

so i rekon you could do it man

but vaccuum cleaner would burn out

your best bet is go to the dump and get a little domestic fridge pump and run it continously with a bleeder

make a bag out of bagging tubing and seal the ends with mastic

run the tube over the mastic strip and use a sheet or bubble wrap for a breather

yeah thats it man

i think the hand pump may do it but its probably even cheaper and better to use the fridge pump