i’ve made a few vaguely like this. mine are similarly chunky, although basic stubbed tails. it’s only a pool toy, so i keep it simple. ;^) you really don’t have huge freedom in dimensions at this size anyway, and at such a short length, it turns plenty without a lot of curve in the rail.
i rode the longest of them, about 5’3" ish some yesterday (standing, not prone). i am similarly about 6 ft 225 lb. they can be very fun, although it’s hard to have one that both kicks and paddles well, as your fore-aft position is so different until they get way short.
my take: since these are usually small/mushy wave monsters, i avoid any vee. if you ride prone, your drag will do a lot of what i feel like vee provides. if you stand up, you’ll need all the lift you can get if you’re a big boy. i do think concaves help hold some of the water underneath, as it’s so easy to have a lot of flow across the axis of the board with such a short and directionally unstable platform-- convert drift into drive as much as possible. over time, i’ve rolled the nose less underneath with less tuck as well, again with area and lift in mind. the belly looks better though as the fat nose looks odd when it doesn’t roll or tuck on bottom. the roll is also easier to hold with hands if you’re prone and kicking, it just steals your energy when it’s marginal. i can’t believe a single will hold the tail in standing, although riding prone your legs serve as fin too. a sizable single will also drag in the trough on a lot of the waves where these are realistic.
these things can be super drifty standing no matter how much fin you use (good luck backside), and there’s not enough rail length to have fins forward. oddly enough, and i’m inviting typical sways abuse by saying this, but i’ve had good results with a tri fin setup right on the tail block. i don’t mean thruster, i mean three smaller fins right on the tail so it has a corner fin to drive off of and somthing in center to straighten it back up and help drive. if you stand, your foot will be right on the tail block, so there’s not really anywhere else to place the fins.
i both agree and respectfully disagree with beerfan. i cut these from light EPS/XPS, as they are inherently strong at this small size and the corkiness helps at this lower edge of push from the surf. also, as you can see in lefty’s post, you have to butcher any regular blank and don’t really get the rocker you want. i disagree with the suggestion to thin the nose. the flex in a booger allows you to do a lot of things that you can’t do on a stiff board. you can dynamically pull back and rocker up on a late drop and push down and flatten out for speed/projection as you move down the transition. once you make a rigid platform, that’s over with. if you rocker it enough to make it comfortable on steeper drops, it’s not paddleable or drivable at all. with the flatter rocker you need to drive laterally, you depend on buoyancy to save the nose in many cases rather than the curve. if you paddle rather then kick (necessary if you’re going to stand), the “bow” is in the drink a lot of the time, and your nose is literally past the nose. when you do a cuttie (again, obviously standing), it’s pretty common to carve about two thirds of the way through the turn off the tail/corner and then drive the nose under as you shift onto your front foot and it starts to drift/release in the last third. that buoyancy is going to save you up front every time when it the nose pops back up and you try to go move back to center and then the opposite rail to continue down the line. even prone, your position is going to be more forward than you think if you can’t push the nose down and flatten out.
i’d say the squirrelly factor is part of the fun, at least if you’re using this as a small wave choice for a bigger fellow. real paipos for serious waves get very different, but as a way-more-fun alternative to a longboard in small, shallow beachbreaks, that’s my (more than) two cents.
-cbg