I think part of the problem with the 7’-9’ “no man’s land”, as the OP puts it has a lot to do with
a point another gentleman made in an unrelated thread recently…
There’s a breaking point where (some/most) can no longer duck dive the board effectively, further
up the height chart there’s a second point where paddling becomes ridiculously fast and easy which
is a great counterbalance for a board that forces you to take a couple sets on the head every
now and then. being between these two points can leave you with the worst of both worlds.
I’ve always ridden boards in the 9’+ range.
I recently finished my first board, a big 7’8" fish and have been surfing it almost exclusively in anything
but the highest tides and am falling madly in love.
I’ve noticed that the board is ridiculously good at keeping itself up in the pocket during pitchy beach
break take offs…I’m making waves and sections I would have NEVER made on a long board. On the
other hand the longer length (relative to other fish) makes it stable and easy to paddle…even duck
divable (it’s a heavy HWS).
Swaylocks has really opened my eyes to all the fun shit I can be goofing around on in the water when
it’s not a longboard day…I seriously considering a mat after reading the matafesto and my Spence
hull should be done in a few weeks.
(http://www.allaboutsurf.com/articles/matafesto)