I just went through this with mine and here is what I found…
Mine is for surfing at 9’4" by 31" by 4". My tail is still pretty wide at 18". I went first with a single, box at 6" up. I put in a 10 inch G and S 'Retro", ton of area on it, 9 inch base. The board surfed well with it but I could pop the fin out easily when up on the nose or close to it. I put in two side fins and though I do feel the drag, no more slide slipping when noseriding and it seems to cutback with more drive. The side fins are standard issue templates from a thruster I had laying around and they are in a typical 2 plus 1 arrangement.
I can still turn the board around on a pivot while paddling-something I had to have.
I hear ya, the fins with more area def help with stability when you arent moving, I think Larry has put a small fin up in the middle on a SUP to help out with straight line paddling. I read somewhere too that long base and low height work well.
I went with lots of area just for that reason, to keep the board stable when I am not moving, it really helps. I turn the board mostly from the tail on a pivot and then run up for trim though with its pulled outline, it will carve some from the back third.
Yeah, not even my 10’0" log with massive tail kick would need a 10 inch fin!
MDS that is my 12 footer that Larry installed the dagger fin in the middle part of the board (10 inches forward of where you would stand or 25.4 cm). Helps a lot for keeping the board tracking in a straight line. It probably adds some lateral stability as well based on the fact that my wife with no experience on a stand up board took it out the other day with swell bumping around in the ocean and only fell off once.
When I get home tonight I will measure the fin box on my board. That should give you an idea for placement, although Larry thought it should probably be a little further forward.
Hi mds, Please feel free to check out my SUP Fins blog at www.standupfinsbylarryallison.blogspot.com I think that blog will answer some of your questions from the reviews my friend. Mahalo,Larry