Glassing a hollow wood...??

I’m getting close to finishing my first hollow wood construction. The next dilemma is how to glass it. Just looking for some input on what the norm is out there? Epoxy or Poly? Will epoxy give me that ultra clear look I am looking for to preserve the craftsmanship (I’ve heard you have to paint it or it might yellow)? Any input would be appreciated. The board is all cedar. I have made some minor repairs with poly but never glassed a whole board. I am scared as hell that I’m going to screw up my hard work with a crapy glassing job but I am determined to do it all myself. I have a good buddy who is going to help me out with the glassing…he has done several boards. Him being present take some pressure off.

Thanks in advance…

G’day upone,

first of all congratulations on an awesome looking board!

I can’t really offer any advice on how or what to glass it with as I am in the same position as you with my first hollow wooden right now.

but I am sure I speak for many others here when I ask you for some more pics of that baby and maybe even some progress shots, that would be great please.

good luck with glassing

Beautiful outline, I love it. My advice is, glass the board with the stuff you can afford ($$) I glassed my board with choped strand mat and poly resin, heavy as hell but cheap and resistant. Board is now 2 years old and looks like new, no dents or dings yet, just som scratches here and there, and no delamination problems.

I you have the money, buy epoxy and go for it. glassing a board is not as difficult as building one.

Can you post the measurements of your board? I want something like that, in the 8’ range.

Jack

Beautiful work

I think you raised an interesting point on the cosmetics of epoxy. Many people on the HWS threads have been recommending epoxy, but I’ve also heard yellowing can be a problem. Not what you want when the board is that beautifull. That being said… EPS/epoxy boards that I’ve seen haven’t yellowed even after a couple years of use, while traditional PU/polyester boards do.

Anyone have insight on this particular aspect?

Pat

use epoxy

it has more fleibility so it wont crack

it also will penetrate into the wood better with higher peel strength

use a good e-cloth

it shouldnt yellow (depends on brand)but very hard to see on wood anyway.

dont ruin your great work with a unsuitable resin

Due to the inconsistent results of polyester resin to bond with wood, Epoxy resin should always be used for lamination…

Resin Research Epoxy Resin is the only stuff I use…Water clear, will not yellow…The same can’t be said about System 3-SB112…

Before laminating a cedar board, I suggest brushing on a single coat of epoxy resin to seal the wood…Cedar had been known to delaminate due to the resinous nature of the wood…This helps prevent that…

One layer of fiberglass cloth on the bottom and two on the top and are adequate…

The sanding coats are epoxy resin with a sanding additive…

After sanding the board, a polyester resin gloss coat can be applied, followed by wet sanding and a high gloss polish…

That’s what I do, I hope that helps…

Paul

Epoxy Resin Tips

by: Greg Loehr

Below I’m writing some tips on making our stuff easier to use. If you take your time, epoxy is actually easier to laminate than polyester, uses much less material and eliminates harmful chemicals in the factory.

  1. Mix ratio must be adhered to. Deviation from the mix ratio will keep the resin from attaining a full cure. Also, the material must be THOROUGHLY mixed. If not there can be soft spots. We use metered buckets (I’m sending you one which we get at the local hardware store) to assure proper mix. We use large paint stir sticks (like the ones hardware stores give you to stir paint). All our resins are 2 to 1 mix ratio by volume. The metered buckets work unreal, actually better than pumps and we laminate right out of those buckets.

  2. Additive F. We use it in every batch we shoot, including laminates. It eliminates blush, which is the biggest problem in building epoxy boards. It only takes 1cc per ounce of hardener in the mix. We put it in after pouring the resin and hardener into the bucket and then mix them all at once. It makes the resin a bit cloudy but clears out when the resin cures.

  3. When laminating, the first thing to do is to pour all the resin out and spread it over the glass. You then wet the rails and tuck them. This gives the resin time to soak into the cloth on the flats. Polyester must be pushed through the cloth. Epoxy just soaks in and it does that in its own good time. It can’t and shouldn’t be forced. Additive F actually helps with this quite a bit. After it soaks in, squeegee out any air and remove any excess. We use plastic, “spreader,” type squeegees. We’ve found that they move epoxy better than rubber squeegees do. They take a couple boards to get wired but after the initial learning curve, laminating is much easier.

  4. We use VERY little resin. Below is an example of our use levels for different size boards. As there is no “gel” time, any resin left over can be used on the next board. If you run short, you can easily mix up additional resin to finish with. Usually we just work out of one bucket and simply keep mixing more material as needed. It isn’t the same, “this bucket for this board,” as polyester.

These are estimates for total mixed material.

6’ and under - 9 -12 oz. bottom 12-15oz. deck

7’ and under - 12 -15oz bottom 15-18 oz. deck

8’ and under - 18 - 21 oz bottom 21- 24 oz. deck

9’ and under - 24 - 27 oz bottom 27- 33 oz deck

Hot coats run just a bit more than an ounce per foot. For instance, a 6’ board would take about 7 oz. per side. Longboards, 9’, take about 12-15 oz. per side. If you’re glossing use a bit less than a hot coat.

We use 3" disposable white bristle brushes for hot coating. We don’t clean them. We use them for one batch and pitch em. Not only do we feel that their not worth cleaning but we’ve also had problems in the past with contamination from cleaned brushes which manifested itself in bad hot coats. New brushes always make for clean hot coats.

  1. Do not use acetone for clean up and never let contaminated acetone touch the skin. Any toxicity problems we’ve seen in the past always included contaminated acetone. Not only that but acetone doesn’t work that well with epoxy anyway. Leaves everything sticky. For your hands use disposable vinyl gloves. Clean gloves between boards with scrap fiberglass. I usually cut scrap and pile it neatly on the table so I have plenty ready. Clean your squeegee with scrap glass. Anytime the squeegee gets slick I just wipe it and my gloves down. When the gloves get funky, peel em off and put on a new pair. 10 cents a pair is cheaper than acetone. With so little resin being used very little goes anywhere except on the board so things tend to stay much cleaner. We don’t ever get more than a drop or two on us. If you do get some on you, use Go-Jo or Fast Orange or some other waterless cleaner with water to get it off. These clean epoxy more effectively and are much safer to use than acetone.

Different Resins & Hardeners

Mixing hardeners for custom applications is one of the reasons we made everything 2 to 1.

With fast, you have a 25 min pot life, slow 50 min and extra slow 200 min. Slow has 4-6 hours flip time; fast has 2-3 hours flip time.

Mixing different hardeners together will give you other results and there isn’t any algebra necessary.

Additive F

First, as I’ve stated earlier Additive F is a miracle breakthrough in the production of epoxy surfboards. It does so many things it’s unbelievable.

In laminating, it helps wet the cloth eliminates most air bubbles, especially around wings and boxes, reduces the amount of resin needed, and most of all eliminates blush. Blush is what causes the banana peel effect you were referring to. In hot coats it eliminates blush, fish eyes, and other surface blemishes and increases Barcol hardness. This increase in Barcol makes the board sand easy and improves the bond and strength between layers.

It also doesn’t interfere with recoating as wax solution in polyester does. That means no sanding between layers. One of the things I’ve tried to relay on this site is that epoxy boards have become easier to make (and safer as well) than polyester boards. Somehow I don’t think that has gotten through.

Additive F reduces resin use by about 20% in laminates.

How much?:

1cc per ounce of hardener = Laminations

2cc per ounce or hardener = Hot/Gloss Coats

Laminating Tips

Epoxy doesn’t need to be pushed into the fabric. If you do this it will get frothy. [GO SLOW].

The first thing to do after mixing is to pour all the resin on the board and spread it around so the entire surface is covered.

The first pass is merely spreading the resin out over the cloth leaving it very wet. Then let it soak. Move the resin from the middle towards the ends. Don’t push towards the middle. That way you won’t rake the glass. This is the really hard part to explain to people that are used to polyester. Letting the resin soak in instead of pushing.

Then wet your laps by pulling resin off the flats onto the lap. This gives the resin time to soak into the flats. Also, use a stiff squeegee that moves the resin more effectively. I use one of those plastic spreaders, the yellow ones. After you wet and tuck the laps, the resin should have sufficiently soaked into the flats with no elbow grease. Now simply remove the excess while flattening the fabric and clean your laps. It’s that simple. Also by pouring all the resin out immediately you reduce exotherm and lengthen work time. Using the above technique I laminated a 12 foot board with a 3 layer 6 oz deck the other day with our new fast hardener in 85º with time to spare.

Hot Coat Tips

Hotcoating/Gloss Coats:

With RR epoxy you double the amount of additive F when hotcoating or glossing, they are the same mix. For glossing/hotcoating you add 2cc of F for every ounce of hardener used. When you laminate you just use 1cc per oz. So , yes…just another layer…with double the F…

There are some simple rules to glossing:

  1. Everything must be clean. That’s the board, the room, the brush, the bucket and everything else that might come in contact with the resin. Contamination will surely ruin your gloss coat.

  2. I usually sand to 100 for glossing. I’ve seen others go to as far as 220 but I’ve never seen the advantage to the extra work. 100 is just fine.

  3. You’ll never get a good gloss using a squeegee, you have to use a brush. It takes a certain amount of resin for it to be able to “flow out”. Using too little and the resin can’t move and self level. This does add a bit more weight than getting it really thin but it’s the only way to get that show room finish. If you don’t want the extra weight then go for a sanded finish.

  4. With Additive F you can polish RR epoxy. In fact it polishes just about like polyester. Without Additive F epoxy doesn’t polish well at all.

  5. When glossing with epoxy double the amount of Additive F. This will give you better flow and your gloss will come out flatter.

As for urethane finishing, this takes really good equipment and a VERY clean spray booth with a constant flow of fresh air. Most of us aren’t set up to do this reasonably. I’ve done a good bit of this and it’s a real professional type of effort to even attempt it. As much as I did, I never had the equipment to get the consistent results I wanted. This is also VERY toxic.

The dry spots on the rails are probably from oil in your hands. All hands have a certain amount of oil. Wiping the board down with denatured alcohol will help remove this. By the way, denatured alcohol is ethanol with 5% wood alcohol which makes it poison. They put a small amount in so people can’t drink it since ethanol (grain alcohol) is what is in alcoholic beverages.

Temperature:

Keeping a small room between 60º and 85º isn’t that difficult and gives consistent quality results.

The new fast hardener is fine above 50º. Additive F will solve many climate problems as well.

At less than 70º time is usually not an issue. Fast hardener has plenty of work time and you can still flip it in less than 5 hours. Slower curing agents like our slow or the surf source resin doesn’t allow you to flip in less than 12 hours, or even more, in cooler temps. Also when the resin doesn’t kick in a reasonable amount of time, bad things happen. Again Additive F eliminates these problems and a faster curing agent always gets better results in cool temps.

Keep Additive F warm to keep the solids in solution.

Epoxy hot coat disaster

I’ve made a major blunder whilst hot coating the deck of my first timber hollow board. I’m using epoxy. I brushed it on to the deck and it looked ok, but an hour later it had gone all pitted and wavy. It hasn’t delaminated, but there are areas which are still sticky (toffee like) even after 4 days. …Gray

Re: Epoxy hot coat disaster

I’m sure that there is an easier way, but I’ll pass on my disaster correction. I used a hair dryer and a scraper. After I got most of the non set up epoxy off, I went through a BUNCH of sand paper… Jeff Wells

Re: Epoxy hot coat disaster

Jeff has it exactly right. Always be sure to THOROUGHLY mix epoxy. It is not a catalytic reaction like polyester so each part (resin and hardener) has molecules that must react with the other part. It’s called an addition reaction. If they don’t get together they won’t kick. Thorough mixing is the solution and an easy one at that. We use big paint stir sticks, they do a better job than tongue depressors. One good thing about having this problem…you won’t ever do it again…. Greg Loehr

Greg Loehr

e-mail:

Resin Research

131 Tomahawk Dr.

Indian Harbour Beach, Fl. 32937

Ph. 321-779-2369

Resin Research

4231 S. Fremont Av.

Tucson, Az. 85714-1628

Ph. 321-223-5276

Thanks for the compliments! I’ll post some progress pictures up soon.

The board is 8’*23.25"*3".

Paul, Thanks, some great info in your posts!

I went to fiberglasssupply.com and came up with the following based on your estimates:

Maybe about 20oz to coat the wood before glassing (top and bottom - 10oz each)

8’ and under / 18 - 21 oz bottom 21- 24 oz. deck

and for the hoat coat I’m estimating about 11oz per side.

So, on the high side, I should need about 90oz. (so I should be good with the

3 Quart Kit Resin Research Epoxy 2000 w/ 2100 fast Hardener [$52.48])
What type of glass should I use? Weight for bottom/top? I heard recomendations of e-glass, but now I see there are different types (Warp Bias and regular)(it only comes in 3.7oz or 5.6oz - so I’m assuming you meant one 3.7oz layer on the bottom and two 3.7oz layers on the top…is this correct?)
Approx. how much weight do you think glassing the board adds?
Thanks again!!
Ralph

Where else can a person ask for a little advice, and nearly instantly be inundated with it. If only more of you guys were in government, i get the feeling the world would be a more compassionate place…

Here’ s my unscientific but practical two cents:

We’ve tried West System, Resin Research, 2 types of System 3, and MAS epoxies. I think the West System gets a bad rap for yellowing partly the because the hardner is yellow. Actually for light colored wood, like Northern White Cedar, it gives it a nice warmer tone. I actually kinda like that and I certainly don’t bash West System for that.

But I do bash them to hell for clouding up. And I’m not talking about Amine Blush either. I’m talking about subsurface cloudiness. It’s happened every time I’ve used it. It might be just because our shop is not warm enough. But I’ll tell you this, it really suck to work for a month, perfecting the woodwork, just to have a bad glass job negate it all.

Personally I like the the Resin Research for all the same reason talked about by others. I especially like it for the flexibility in modulus. We use the most flexible one. MAS and the two System 3 brands worked just as well so the point about using what you can afford makes some sense.

Right now i have a fish on the glassing rack, and am bout to try the Silver Tip brand. I;ll let you know how it works.

We primarily use 3.7 oz E-glass (1 on top, 1 on bottom with either a lap or zip on the rails). On occasion we’ve use 6 0z for spots that got sanded thin. We usually do a sealer coat, followed by the lam and 1 or 2 sand coats. No varnish or poly.

As for weight, I recently did a 6’9 with the above schedule. i think it weighed 11 pounds before glassing and just under 15 after. But then again, that was an early method.

Ralph, Thanks for keeping us up to date with your project. Something to be proud of and looks awesome, That puppy is going to surf like butter. So cool.

FYI still working on that Bonzer design, so sweet.

Just thought of one more question before I end my long midnight shift…

At what stage do you guys install you vent plug? Before or after glassing?? THANKS!

you don’t have to have the actual vent in before you glass but you can just drill the hole and stick a straw out of it or something, some guys glass with the vent installed too.

as the resin cures it rises in temp this creates pressure inside the board and POSSIBLE cracks, explosion maybe!

My buddy who is going to assist me glassing sent me this e-mail…

Quote:
Ralph,

Hey, Good stuff!! Board Looks hott!!!

Ummm as far as that brand of Epoxy, no I haven’t had much experiance with it. I’ll do some reserch though. Some things I did want to point out though… Yellowing… Yes that is a problem w/ Epoxy unless you use a Clearcoat or something with UV protectants. If it was my board, I’d Use West Sytem Epoxy with a Ultra Clear hardener. after light sanding, I’d spray the board with Awlgrip Clear coat. Awlgrip being one of the most durable paints on the market. So if that is a thought, the Alwgrip that is… You just have to make sure the resin is compatable with Awlgrip. Remember… Epoxy’s Come in all different formulas soo Epoxy might not be Epoxy!!!

We’ll talk more about it later.

Trev

Does anyone have any experience with Awlgrip clear coat? Or know if its compatable with Resin Research Epoxy???

Opinions??

We’ve been down this road before. My understanding - Yellowing happens to the foam. To keep the Foam from yellowing resin companies put additives in their mix to protect it.

Yellow resins - yes there are some/many - are that way from the start. They don’t yellow - they Are yellow.

The RR epoxy that I’ve used as clear or clearer than s249a polyester. No need for clear coat - especially over wood.

If you have a heated area to glass the board (out east there) you should be fine.

EJ

I built a hollow wood in 2000/2001 out of aviation grade sitkas spruce. Yours looks great and brings back lots of memories. That perfect creation, with deck panels to the precision of inlaid wood art. And the last thing you want is to ruin it, or even compromise the magnificant wood beauty.

I used polyester resin, but I strongly recommend using epoxy. In 2000 the characteristics of epoxy were not what they are now, and everyone was suspicous of epoxy it seemed. It wouldn’t polish like you want for such a wood board. But today is different. I recommend Resin Research epoxy (see Greg Loehr’s comments previously). Additive F will do wonders for the resin perfomance adhering to the wood surface. And follow Greg’s instructions on the gloss coat with doubling the additive F.

Using polyester resin one had to first paint a layer of resin onto the wood to assure saturation, as trying to saturate through the cloth by squegee was very difficult and any unsaturated area would be hazy or worse. I would still recommend that presaturation method even with epoxy (but would defer to Greg if he says his RR with double additive F will saturate), but that does mean you will need help laying the cloth down flat the first time (trim after you lay it on the presaturation).

A major benefit of epoxy over polyester in a wood board is that polyester on such a hard surface will crack like a witch’s mirror with even slight impact (like inadvertantly touching the tail to a floor, even lightly). Epoxy will not do that at all. Also, here is a biggy. On your board the strength comes from the wood structure, unlike a foam board that has very little shear strength from the foam. You do not need a heavy glass job to protect or or give strength. If I had mine to do over again I would do only 4oz all the way around. My deck and bottom planks were 1/4" thick to start, I estimate 3/16ths after sanding was complete. My board is an 8’11" mini gun type shape and I only use it in the biggest surf. It has not had one defect to date, and I weigh 210 at 6’2", so I put it to the test. Show us a picture when you get it complete! Good luck.

Thanks for the advice Estan…the board was actually finished last May. That was an older post. I ended up going with RR epoxy like you suggested. Came out great. And as for strenght, the epoxy is amazing! I droped the board from chest high onto my drive way and nothing happened…a poly board would have had a huge ding/crack.

This was the finished product…http://www.newyorksurf.com/modules/ipboard/index.php?showtopic=7613&st=0

I actually just started another HW 6’4" fish.