Hi Ben,
Again, Lee is right, the car floor mat isn’t a pad, it offers zero impact absorption from stomps and such, and it won’t do ya any good, pure and simple. That’s a clear vinyl, not a neoprene foam of some sort. Gawd knows how you’d stick it to the deck, too.
Me, I would go with the repair/reinforcement and a neoprene pad in major traffic areas. The first to fix what has already happened, the second to help keep it from happening again.
Look, this isn’t a Paul Jensen wood Stradivarius of a board or an older ‘classic’, it’s a recent vintage fun shape that isn’t glassed real strong. Use pads, they help. I realise the look of them isn’t stylish, but neither is the browned, waterlogged look of a delammed deck.
Also, like Lee sez, those rounded edges help on a patch, not only blends in appearance-wise but there’s no immediate transitions straight across the board to either trip ya or abruptly change the flex characteristics of the board and trigger a break.
Yeah, Lee and I are double- teaming ya here. There is really no way out of beefing up the deck, not if ya want the board to last a while.
Might be that you can’t see any deck delamination happening yet, but I assure you it’s there under those dents, I have fixed too many of that brand of board to think otherwise. By the time you can see it, it’s too late and the fix is expensive, heavy and in the long run it doesn’t work too well anyhow. Done a lot of those too - miserable, expensive job.
A deck patch will stiffen up the glass that’s there, keep it from coming up and away from the foam and then that tiny delam won’t spread , which is Very Important.
Give ya a paralell example - buddy of mine owns a restaurant. Well, for years we were patching tiles in the kitchen floor, where traffic and underlying weaknesses in the subfloor and such gave the tile no support. Moisture leaked in through the cracked tiles and weakened everything further ( as it will with the dents and tiny, just about invisible cracks on your board ) . It was a pain, and we did it every year to a major part of the floor. Then, we said ‘bag this’ and put down a new subfloor and a new seamless floor system that works like a sonofagun. Haven’t had to do anything since then, and it’s been several years. In terms of time and repairs saved, it’s just about paid for itself. Wish we had done that years before - would have saved my knees considerable wear and tear.
Ok, so that wasn’t such a great example, still, the moral of the story is this:
Do the right thing now- you save a lot of work later.
hope that’s of use
doc…