My opinion is that I hate 80’s-style boards and am so happy we have evolved past them.
However, I understand why some people like them for some of the reasons covered here (paddle better, don’t have to work as hard to surf them well, etc.). Nothing against them or their boards of choice; it’s just not my trip to ride nor do they allow the performance that I like to witness. I’ve never seen an advanced surfer surf better on an 80’s vs. a modern high-performance tri (when the whole “retro 80’s” thing happed a few years ago, a number of truly talented local surfers jumped on the wagon and, in my opinion, their style and performance suffered).
This quote (from the thread-starting post) kinda summarizes my anti-80’s-style boards because, to me, it feels like the design limits performance to what you have described: "but I didn’t actually feel the nose cathing cause I sortof pivot around my back foot. "
IMO, I’d personally rather have to work a little harder and develop the skill to ride thinner-railed boards and be able to put them in and slice through the wave than be forced to only pivot around off the tail without engaging the foreward rail.
And I really enjoy the flow and agression the pros and top-notch local heroes exhibit on modern shortboards. While I am impressed at how the 80’s pros handled their craft, especially in waves of consequence, I can’t help but think how much harder they could be surfing and performing if they were not nursing their thick-railed boards by pivoting off the tail so much and trying to coax those buoyant rails to stay in the water long enough to bring the board back under control and do a neutral-railed recovery. NOTE: of course there are some super-freak exceptions to this- Tom Curren comes to mind, even though I like what he is currently doing on modern equipment more)
Sure those boards cover distance quickly and efficiently, but one it comes time to do business there are better tools in the box (once again, IMO).
If I want that thicker, floatier feel I’m on my “retro” fishes and mod-fishes. Those are my crutch boards when the waves are lacking. Anything chest high and over with a wall and I don’t want to be held back by having to fight the buoyancy of a thick rail.
But as I said, this is my personal opinion and personal choice, not to be held against anyone who chooses the nostalgic approach!