Not meaning to be unkind, as I hope you understand....
You ask:
My true interest was really figuring out if I need to improve my wave count or just focus on surfing better when I am up and riding.
Which is an important question. A quick preamble, if you don't mind....
I do surf beachbreak, most of the time, and I like it. When it's on, it's fast, hollow, crunchy, pick whatever you like. And when it isn't, it's slop. When you get stormy slop, it's a peak and a kickout and that's it. Please don't get me going on the oxymoron of 'wind swell': it ain't, unless the wind is far, far away.
Besides that, well, this summer I'm gonna be 56, and it's definitely the downhill slide for me. My chances of getting seriously better than I am now are fat and slim.
But, back to the main thing here, I found that good days were a lot different than slop days. When you're in a good beachbreak wave, well, it happens fast. It's not something you can plan, things change and your plan turns into a pumpkin. And so you're surfing by what i think of as conditioned reflex. Reacting to the wave.
But the conditioned reflexes you need for a good wave are very different from a slop wave. What works in slop won't necessarily work when it's quick and hollow. Nor vice versa.
And I found that slop was giving me the wrong set of reflexes. When it got good, it was a lot of 'oops' followed by that darned ol' rinse cycle thing again.
Besides which, it was freakin' boring, me and several hundred of not-my-best-friends out there grovelling in the ankle biters. You ever see somebody else get a really good wave and do something really cool with it, and let out a hoot? Something that kinda clicks on the stoke-o-rama for you? It don't happen in slop. Grovelling doesn't produce something you see, get excited by and want to try yourself. It's freakin' depressing is all it is.
So, I became picky. A wave gourmet, selective, one of high standards, an elitist pr!ck if you like. I don't waste my time in slop. Why get frustrated or depressed or just plain p!ssed off?
I have a seven footer for the small or crowded days. It has a nice Penn spinning reel on it, 12 lb test line and I kinda like live bait. I'd rather go fishing than play the wave count game. And, in truth, if it's slop, that is about the only thing you can do, play the wave count game.
But on the good days....ah. The ones that are out, and that can make it out ( beach break, remember), they know what they're doing. They do it well, they are a pleasure to watch, and hoot for when they do something well. And yes, I try my damndest to do something that might deserve a hoot too. There's a challenge to it, it's harder. It's me versus wave, not how-many-of-these-can-I-catch. It's how well can I surf this, can I make it, can I tuck under and get some shade. Can I crank this turn, not can-I-turn-at-all-without-stalling-in-this-slop.
Put it another way: you and I have prolly eaten a lot of crummy hamburgers in our lives. But do you remember( or want to remember) those or do you want to remember a really good steak, cooked just right.
That's what floats my....okay, board. Might not be that way for you, we're all different. But, if you want to improve how you surf and the enjoyment you get out of it, then maybe you want to concentrate on the 'what I do when the board is moving' thing, not wave count.
hope that's of use
doc...