The reason the pros don’t have a legal leg to stand on with pictures in mags is that they are being photographed at a public beach. And since they aren’t minors, there isn’t a conflict.
Plus, as you mentioned, it is a mutual deal. The pros need the paparazzi and vice versa.
As far as an autograph goes, a pro doesn’t have to sign anything he doesn’t want to sign. I can’t make him. But most are cool and sign.
I thought about the marketability of a board with signatures and figured, what’s the point? It couldn’t possible be that valuable. They aren’t the NBA. Heck most surfers cannot name half, heck, ten of the top forty-four surfers. It’s very hard to watch a contest and not want to surf instead. It’s a participatory sport.
Plus, I wouldn’t EVER want to laminate a brand name into my board, like Rip Curl, etc., unless I was sponsored, and I don’t think anyone wants to sponsor a 35 year-old slightly overweight self-thought-of advanced surfer who is really a very, very experienced intermediate surfer who has brief flashes of ripping (in his own mind). I swear, when I surf everyone is watching me. But I know they are not.
And I certainly wouldn’t want to laminate a shaper’s brand name, like CI into a board that wasn’t shaped by Merrick (or ghost). That would be like building a car on my own and putting a Ford symbol on the hood (of course, the quality would probably be equal).
My goal is to get all the current competing world champs, such as Sunny Garcia, Occy, Slater, Irons, Hobgood. Oh, and a few former world champs who will be there, like Rabbitt, Potter, Curren, Duke, etc.