ARCTIC FOAM vs. Surfblanks vs U.S. Blanks

a rats, … yeah I’ll give ya that… don’t want to put too much stock into hydrodynamics and millions of $ in R&D.

We (should) all just live under piers somewhere and shape with an adz like Bear in Big Wednesday.

**“Each board handshaped one at a time, taking countless hours of love, sweat 'n tears in a never ending quest for perfection. Then lovingly cradled in caring hands by the glasser who (also) spends countless hours, even days, obsessing over ONLY YOUR board. Next, the detail oriented craftsman of the group diligently pores over the fin markings and installs the ALL IMPORTANT kook, er… leashcup. Finally, Pigpen, our dedicated sander final shapes your board to perfection!” Any desires beyond this requires the special services of such mystics as pinliners, glossers and polishers, that are flown in special from remote areas of the globe.
**

"THIS is exactly why your board may take several months to get near the finishing stage. The more lauded the shaper, whether he ever touches the board or not, the more you should be willing to wait… all the while singing his praises asy ou turn each page of the calendar patiently waiting for that magic day.

** Five, six, seven months is nothing… there is at least one fantastic story in Sway’s of the East Coast guy that ordered thru a shop and was finally awarded his Brewer after ONLY 15 months.  This guy was TRULY FORTUNATE to receive the board within his lifetime. Many others have planned the names of children they plan to work on with the wife, while placing their order with suring’s greatest shaper diginitaries. THIS IS THE WAY IT IS DONE IN TODAY’S CHALLENGING AND FAST MOVING TIMES. **

REGARDLESS OF WHAT FOAM IS USED, you can rest assured, that somewhere, someone is sanding out the ridges of the master’s original intent for you.

You should be so lucky.

**NOT.
**

**Do you know what the business agreement was? I sure don’t. **

**Funny that when Midget called me from OZ and we talked for the better part of an hour, he didn’t have the tilt that you are taking. He merely wanted my take on things and I don’t have any stake in any foam supplier and don’t receive any freebie blanks for posting this stuff. The last foam I ever got ‘special treatment for’ was Ice Nine because they wanted me to use their foam and give them feedback. Some of it was really good, some had problems, so whatever benefit I got became a wash when they had quality challenges. Look at where Ice 9 is now?
**

**Go back and LOOK at what I said about U.S. Blanks. . They are providing a gold standard of service as far as I’m concerned. Hurley is totally professional, personable and on it. I have been alerted on a Nor Cal run and they’ve had only a couple days lead time and I threw an order together AND STILL GOT THE FOAM anyway. That is super impressive. Especially considering they cut and glued up the order I placed.
**

**I’ve heard good stuff from other friends shaping Millenium…which as far as I’m told, comes from Blair. In the past, people spoke well of Blair’s efforts. And you are right:  producing quality foam is much harder than people may have first imagined in the wake of Clark’s closing.
**

**The bottom line for me, is that YOU are entitled to use whatever foam you want because the buck stops with you. As far as making cheap shots about someone being a trust funder or not, I don’t know if that is a true statement or how you can substantiate that. Do you have access to their tax returns? **

**The guys you are claiming as trust funders… well, one had a modest house by the SB Polo Fields near the bottom of Toro Canyon Rd. where I first bought MIdget’s Surfblanks out of his garage some years ago. The other was a sales rep. that I bought products from as long as 30 years ago. I’ve never witnessed lavish lifestyles from either of them. No yachts, Ferrari’s or mansions, personally owned islands…
**

**Somehow that just doesn’t sound like the trust funders that I have known and grown up with in Santa Barbaria, of which there are many… since we are on this subject, my parents were blue collar middle class and I grew up above SB on the Kinevan Ranch in a cabin that my parents originally rented for $75 per month.
**

Let’s agree that there are some business differences that happened with Midget and their dealings. When MIdge asked me if I thought they could capture the majority of market share in the U.S. I gave him an honest answer, as I did here. I also said “Midget, IF they did have all the pieces fall together in perfect order, I wish they’d make gazillions and could just compensate you in a fair manner so it could become a ‘non-issue’…but that’s in a perfect world isn’t it?”

**He laughed over that. But he also understood that I favor win wins in my dealings and would hope the best for all concerned If you wan to be a fact checker, call or PM him thru Sway’s, and I seriously doubt that he will deny any of what i have stated here It’s a bummer for him to make inroads with his foam into the Unitd States as he has with other places, but for whatever reason, a wrench fell into the machinery and I have no knowledge as to who owns that wrench.
**

Midget is a big boy and he knows that business is business, differences arise, contracts are written and signed to keep people honest or at least within guidelines or confines of a mutually agreed upon contract.

Unles you are omnipotent, or clairvoyant, I doubt you know any more about the details than me.

I put this thread up because it was talking about foam that I had opinions on. Those opinions are based on shaping thousands of boards over decades from different people making foam. Some good, some not so good.

If you want to make your own foam and sing its praises go for it. If you want to shape only EPS, that’s your decision. If you want to tell me to fuck off… that is your perogative. It doesn’t change my feelings of what I’ve experienced from the foam I have shaped or purchased from my suppliers.

**As far as anyone making statements about the foam coming out of Mexico (Baja del Sur to be exact), I don’t have a problem with that versus CHINA taking over the whole fucking world. As I recall, there were a lot of Aussies that flocked to China as well paid advisors thereby selling out anyone and everyone along the way. And the guys that love Harold Walker… probably the salt of the earth, as far as I was told, sold his formula to Asia as well. I figure the United States would be better off trying to develop better business relationships with Mexico and Canada than giving it all to Asia. As it stands, American gun dealers are making a fortune supplying the drug cartels south of the border. **

**There is also a LOT of ignorance concerning what is required of a modern day factory in Mexico. The idea that no restraints of manufacturing, employees having rights and fair wages is an antiquated notion. If you don’t believe me, look into what is involved in a business start up in Mexico. I spend a fair amount of time in Mexico and have friends with businesses that are Mexican and old stereotypes are a cheap shot at an entire culture. I know plenty of white flojos in my own home town.
**

**
**

**Tim Stamps told me he did not like the Arctic, of which he gets a couple every once in awhile. He said the glue ups from the stringers produced little glue balls that created ‘skiffle tracks’ across the foam when he is fine sanding his boards out. In contrast, i had done more than a couple dozen previous to his statement without experiencing that at all. Go figure. Bottom line is his preference is toward “crispier outside foam” versus a hard yet resilient foam. Both “Surfblanks” and “Arctic” have harder resilient foam characteritics. The easiest to mow and quickly handshape with a regular planer blade is USB Blue. The foam that dents the easiest is the USB Blue.
**

Everyone is entitled to shape what they like, whether it is polyurethane, EPS, extruded. balsa, redwood, coconut or whatever the hell…

All  know is that in the past decade, I have tried a lot of different foam being claimed to be wonderful, or green, or consistently hard through the entire blank… some of it was pure shit. Some gassed, some had crooked stringers, some yellowed horribly, some sucked resin like a well paid ho.

**Shape what you like, and like what you shape.
**

 

**
**

Interesting thread Dead…

 Speaking of improved trade with Canada and Mexico… PM me your shipping address , I 've got something for you…

To be absolutely fair, you could have included Composite  /  EPS… as a viable " vs " also… I think it’s future is more promising and exciting than the any PU foam especially with all the flexible plastic mesh binders and cork skins in use now…

Hell …Huie’s doing a form of urethane rubber rail system  I believe, similar to the Lib Tech boards…  I imagine…

 

 I’m just getting into PU foam, shaping a couple of US red’s I got for a good price… Kind of a shit’s and giggles thing having never used the foam before…

 

. I can tell you strictly from gut feeling, just handling the PU foam I have, that it’s NOT ideal for what I do, as it’s too limiting, unless you use the super light   Pink  or   Yellow foams that allow you to skin the board accordingly for better longevity  as witnessed in  Huie’s latest creations…  You’d have to glass the shit out of PU to make it last and hold up to heavy  day to day kite surf duty…  It would be better / lighter to “location” skin it…

From what I’ve read Marko and US EPS is of very good quality…Combined with good epoxy or Resin X it’s a good  “vs”  in this  hypothetical - competition…

Multi density  EPS   by CoreFusion…??? Who Knows…

PU seems to be stuck in time …  Imho…   Sure, I’ts white, it’s fast production, it’s  the most recognized  and excepted standard for years…BUT…

 

Yes I agree.

PM sent. and thanks.

Huie is VERY innovative… ever see his cnc fins?

He’s pretty active for a ‘retired’ guy!

I expect a good grillin’ is in store for me on the (now) were tops now comment… lol

 

 

Hey DS, I think I was probably a bit over the line, so please forgive me for being so judgmental.  I don’t have a ax to grind with the arctic guys, but I did have and inside guy, that used to work at Clark, and whose brother is a well respected North Shore shaper who came up with the SB trust fund part, so he was my source on all things going on at Surfblanks America.   I wish anyone who wants to make foam success, because for the cottage surfboard industry to survive it needs readily available good quality foam.  Surfblanks were always stronger than pretty much anything in PU, and its good they got rid of that noxious gassing that my friend Midget Smith used to complain about.  As for it being from Ensenada, well that’s still better than China, so I agree with you, there.  I haven’t heard anything but good about the foam, so that’s about it.  For quite a long time I have had total respect for you going back to those funny ads in the mags, and of course your love of shaping, and surfing, and your as much of a SB legend as anyone, except for John Bradbury, but he’s gone now, and he was so cool, and unpretentious, and always called it as he saw it, and maybe hopefully there still some of that in me.

Thank you.

JB was a friend and peer in my life. I am 100% self taught as a shaper, but it was glassing many of John’s shaped blanks that influenced me as to what a surfboard should be.

As far as the ‘trust fund’ thing. You know… kids get born into a family and if they are fortunate they have parents that are motivated to be successful or at least care enough about providing for their families to set funds aside versus spending it all on themselves. Growing up in Santa Barbara I have known many families that a mom or dad has enjoyed great success at something whether it be starting a motel or restaurant chain, conceiving an invention and patenting it, or enjoying some level of sports, musical, or acting celebrity.

The stereotypical reaction is to hold it against the offspring. Yet they were kids born into a family of wealth or financial savvy and are merely the recipient of their elders wisdom. Some end up poor little rich boys and girls. Others go on to do honorable work and sometimes very giving projects. As Kit Tremaine, Santa Barbara’s most famous philanthripist once told me “I was fortunate to be born under a money tree, and the leaves just kept on falling”.

It’s not how much you have, it’s how you choose to spend it.

Stingray...aka...backyard guy....and backyard glasser.

EPS foam can tell me the denesity....1.5 or 1.75 or close to it....Just picked up some 2.5 EPS blanks...Nice....too bad the guy went out of business. It's good foam.

I like knowing the density of the foam. I like the density the same all the way through. EPS....

Poly gives me a "color"...Blue, Red, yellow...or a "name" ultralite, superblue...ect...It's a big guessing game unless you are a Pro with inside information. Thanks for the information Deadshaper. Or maybe it's non information designed to keep people like me off track...........That's OK...I get it.......I'm ready to go back to cutting my own but space is an issue.

 

Have a great day..........Ray........

 

 

Hey Bruce I appreciate your straightforwardness, and am glad that someone is producing blanks.   Still according to the model first laid out By Adam Smith in his seminal work: “The Wealth of Nations”, I believe we would be better served as a country, if the foam was built here In the USA; especially if were claiming to be no. 1.  i can’t expect many around here to read the thing, but really it should be required reading for everyone.  As for your accusations of me being stereotypical, that is myopic at best.  I don’t need to ingratiate myself by telling you, how well I speak Spanish, or understand and am a part of Mexican culture, because that’s way too small, so I will let that go.  I try to just say it here as I see it, and more often than not its misunderstood around here. 

As for JB, I miss hanging out with with him, like in his backyard on the mesa, going over designs, and how to make his stuff better, having a couple drinks, and just having a good time talking about surfing, and passing the time, in that funny little Santa Barbara surfy-world, with the divide between the haves, and the have nots.  Yeah, back then we’d talk what everyone were doing, and or, screwing.  He got me in trouble more than once with people- even my with my wife,  and a part of me died when he did.  What a cool man.

I wasn’t actually singling you out in the stereotypical statement… I meant 'all of us tend to (stereotype)… more correctly. Things like Asians are the best students, but bad drivers, Indians can’t hold their alcohol, black people are afraid of water… white men can’t jump.

Everybody has their own list, whether they know it or not.

People judge… that’s why there are juries.

I should put “The Wealth of Nations” on my reading list. It is no doubt a great read, and something worth consideration.

The importance of a nation’s ability to manufcature things, particularly a super power cannot be dismissed. No country in history has ever been able to maintain super power status when they gave up their ability to make things. Egypt, Rome, Greece, the Byzantine, Incan, Mayan empires were all productive entities.

History IS important, because it allows us to learn from our mistakes. As far as the production of foam by a neighbor, versus domestic, I can only point out that our representatives up on Capitol Hill are the ones who decided on directions that pushed a lot of jobs offshore.

People will debate that, but when it comes down to it, you have 520 that say they are not to blame and nothing could be further from the truth. They ARE to blame because they are, or supposed to be, representing us.

They don’t. It’s myth. They represent Wall Street, the 1%, huge corporations, special interest groups with powerful lobbyists. I’m not any party affiliation per se, because it doesn’t make a sh-t bit of difference whether you are Republican or Democrat, Independent or Technocrat or Liberterian… get ANYONE of them a leader in the ‘highest position’ in the land and they will be ‘neutalized’ within their first 100 days by ‘the system’…the machine that keeps fleecing the middle class even in the wake of the bubble bursting.

That’s all it ever was anyway… a bubble of perceived wealth that banks and Wall Street got people to extend themselves with the illusion that the entire nation was all together in new found levels of wealth.

Not.

…reminds me of “The Emporer’s New Clothes”.

Be on your guard for the new "things are getting better…the economy is rebounding…more jobs are becoming available… ALL MANIPULATION for a re election. IT’S BUSINESS AS USUAL.

NOW GET TO WORK AND PAY ME YOUR TAXES.

To take your premise one step further DS, it was Congress that forced the mortgage lenders to supply "affordable" loans and housing. In particular it was Christopher Dodd and Barney Franks that forced the issue. They mandated the housing bubble. It is all detailed in a very easy read and a short read in a book by Thomas Sowell. Government, BIG GOVERNMENT is at the root of it all.

I agree 100% with you on the election process. I'm wondering if I'm even going to vote this time. It would be a first for me.

Great insights, DS, and the whole thing seems to be barely holding on.  My guess is Mexico isn’t that bad right now, if the President sent his 13 year old daughter down there for spring break with 25 secret service guys to make sure she’s OK.  And if she makes a mistake, well the new health care stuff will pay for it.  Party on!!!

Tblank I am going to look for that book by Sowell.  So do you think he draws on Hobbes seminal work “Leviathan”?  Those books I mentioned, “The Wealth of Nations” and “Leviathan” are fundamental to begin understanding the minds of people like Washington, Jefferson, and Madison.

Hey G, I'm sure Sowell is familiar with and has used those tomes for foundational thought. The name of his book is: "The Housing Boom and Bust". I got it on Amazon for about $10.00 new. It is only about 150 pages but it says plenty, particularly with Cal. in mind. He is/was a professor at Stanford so he knows Cal. politics.

For those who are less likely to turn pages, rent “Inside Job” narrated by Matt Damon. It gives you some pretty solid insight as to the whole ‘credit crunch’, AIG, Wall Street manipulation went down. Bernicke and Geisel (sp?) and others that sucked off the system end up RIGHT BACK IN high up positions thanks to our current hip president.

If you voted for the current puppet, like me, you end up watching this gravely disappointed. You realize Republicans and others suggesting to let the banks fail (heaven forbid), had more merit than first given. You see at least one high up asshole cornered with the truth respond knowing he is ABOVE THE LAW.

Don’t forget, law is always subject to interpretation. How lawyers interpret the law can get so ‘creative’ that the intent pf that law can me twisted and misconstrued to become meaningless or even contrary to its original intent.

The ‘protections’ you assume are in ‘your best interest’ may in fact, bury you.

Welcome to America, the land of opportunity.

Back to foam - any experience with Eskimo blanks anyone ?

Yeah, good call, Poli Sci class is over for today… since we are asking questions is Arctic the King Mac formula? Or is Blair KIng Mac? Lots of shapers loved the stuff… the big deal never went through.

Is the Segway poly foam MDI? Anyone ever used that?

Personally I finally came to the conclusion that MDi based foam SUCKS. For a different read check my TDI vs MDI thread awhile back…

Whatever happened to Rhino Foam?

In the meantime… my money is on ARctic becasue I have a stack of testimonials from guys famous for destroying decks that are still smiling at how durable the foam is.

The MOST durable is what The Duke is riding below:

Shaped quite a few of Midget's  blanks on Maui.  More time consuming than US Blanks, but a nice white finished blank.  Very dent resistant and glassed  lighter due to less resin absorbed.  Surfblanks America was essentiallly the same thing. Doubt like hell that Arctic has any kind of Blair or King-Mac connection.  A local now defunct shop on Maui brought in King-Mac and their were glue up and discoloration issues.  End of story.  They never really got off the ground in Ensenada.  I belive Terry Martin shaped some of the plugs.  After shaping a couple, he disavowed himself from the company.  Blair is a name you here from time to time and I even knew of someone who went to work for them.  I've yet to see one of their blanks anywhere. Most likly the guys from Surfblanks America had a chemical analysis done of the bulk formula they were recieving from Midget and then turned the stolen formula into Artic Foam.  Gambling on the fact that a relativley small Australian company is not going to most likly lawyer up for an International law suit.  Midget got it from Grubby and now he gets it from these guys.

I just threw some of that conjecture to see what people would come back with.

As far as ‘analyzing Midget’s formula’ I can say with a ‘high degree’ of certainty… not even.

A lot of investment went into the branding of Surfblanks America. As far as I know the licensee is still intact and if the foam is as good as everyone would want and expect it to be, there would be no reason not to offer two different formulas of foam like Segway or  Surfblanks/Teccel or some other companies out there.

Some companies may prefer to offer a TDI and  EPS or MDI based foam product, or extruded or who knows what… we’ve seen foam based with soy, with cane, what else?. Even USB’s  Orange to Red to Blue to Green have siginifcant different characterisitics and configurations under a microscope… Clark offered very high density sheet foams back in the day and a customer could specify things like perforated or other preparations on those products.

Arctic is considerably different from Surblanks. The similar traits are only that, similar. If you doubt me, maybe take a ride down Baja way for a visit and see maybe you’d see some S/B formula still sitting in barrels. If it was a primo as you would want, and not being used, that would be a move like pissing upwind.

 

HEY FRANK!  Call down to George and tell him to print 20K more copies, we got a hot one going!!

 

hey dead’’  i dont have a prbm if you want to promo foam corps or whoever the fuck there name is?

 

 but whats with the bucketing of midgets foam  not sure i understand?

 

 

**  cheers huie
**

Huie… what I’m saying is that there is always a market for good foam…from anyone from anywhere. I mentioned in this thread I still have some Surfblanks, even shaped one for a close friend a couple weeks ago… board is strong as a rock.

But the point I was saying is… shit happens. Maybe, just maybe there were some problems that caused these guys to go another way?  It costs a lot of dough to set up, promote, stock, distribute, establish the identity, on and on. I don’t think ANYONE takes changing a business lightly in this day and age with a down economy and the expense involved. What else aren’t we getting?

Is it anyone’s business but the parties involved? Not really.

What I’m saying then is IF Surfblanks were premium quality with virtually NO problems whatsoever, and if the material didn’t become uncompetitive due to price, then there isn’t a lot of seeable reason why they would discontinue offering it. Maybe the plan was to offer BOTH, or expand their product offering along the line that Ice 9 did when they brought Harold Walker into the fray and created “MoWses” which the “W” stood as an homage to Walker. They had “Cane” and “Able” which most people never even heard of their “Able” formula. The Cane was actually pretty good a lot of the time, but there were some challenges with it that forced them toward a polyurethane TDI bade foam, and the timing was there with Walker.

I imagine there are quite a few people that would use Surfblanks in the U.S. if it were to be disributed again. As it stands, the parties that are involved are probably in limbo or a Mexican stand off. I have to be honest here… the Surfblanks I did for my buddy glassed out very strong. It reminded me how much I didn’t ever like shaping that foam. Midget always maintained that the foam is “surfer friendly” … and I respect him for producing his foam to benefit the end user. Not a problem for all the guys that machine everything too. But being a handshaper, I would burn out shaping the stuff and in my head I started calling it the “surfer friendly, fuck you shaper” foam.

When it comes to Arctic, the foam shapes easier than the SB’s that I had. Now this was before the Yellows came into play, and I neve shaped one. I think Andrew gave me one to try, but I never got to it… it was a tiny little thing and I was waiting for th right guy to do it for. My budget was a lot tighter then and  couldn’t just glass it up and throw it out there. Probably should have but that was then and this is now. The Surfblanks I still have are Blue or Green, whatever th most commonly used density was/is. The took it out of my old shaper body so I still look at it as the “fuck you shapers” foam.

**Now the Arctic is only a “semi fuck you shapers” foam. It finish sands easier. The stuff machines really well too. My personal opinion is, if all you are doing is machining everything, THEN YOU SHOULD go for a hard foam… but if you handshape, the most “shaper friendly foam” s U.S. Blanks. The Blues shape very easily, curiously enough the Red density doesn’t shape quite as easily even though it is lighter… the orange, I haven’t tried. Some of their foams have cells that stack up differently that possibly contribute to a plus or minus shaping experience. **

**All i know is there is SOME reason the Surfblanks aren’t still being blown and distributed. Maybe there was a problem and no one wants to take blame. I recall Grubby always feeling his foam never had problems. I think that’s kinda myopic… foaming is not fool proof. It’s part science and part art, and if anything, we have seen plenty of startups and claims, and bright spots as well as disasters in the wake of Clark’s closure. **

Some guy chimed in on this thread about EPS… well, I have some affinity for EPS and started using it in the early 80’s while doing sailboards and some sufboads. But the early day stuff from Western Insulfoam was crap compared to today. White Hot was a subsidiary of a huge building supply company and their stuff was very consistent, as was Austin… but it was a tough road to get surfers behind it, just as Marko has found, and U.S. Blanks picked up the first two mentioned here. Still, historically it has been very difficult to exactly know what density the EPS foam is… regardless of the earlier post someone made here. 2.0 is not exactly 2.0… it’s usually in the neighborhood of 2 lb. I’ve used bastard EPS that was really light that they thought was closer to .8 lb and I still hav some really nice 2.5 lb from White Hot before Western Building canned the program.

**If we go back to machining… cutter generally hate milling EPS, even though Surfding mentioned the appropriate speed and method for doing it with success. **

If some says “machine extruded foam because that is hard foam too”. Okay great, I hope you know all the secrets regarding it’s vulnerabilities around heat. I still have a almost new C.I. XTR that had the micro holes drilled into it that was supposed to be the ultimate solution for using this material. Guess what? The guy brought it to me to stick back together, it had delammed as well as snapped, and he ended up just getting a new PUPE from me. Where’s the value in XTR? I wish anyone well that has had gr success with them… I don’t believe in them almost as much as I don’t believe in M.D.I. based foam. The stuff may be good for wind turbine props or something but it is shit for surfboards.

**So maybe, just maybe Clark has some problems with his foam, and maybe Midget did too. I don’t think any of us will ever really know including you. All I know is what I’m using now, with regualrity, is coming out great and holding up really well, even with chronic abusers. That speaks volumes to me. **

**I’ve been run around the flag pole sooo many times since Clark’s closure, that if I find something consistent and reasonably priced, I’m going to use it and not change chasing some pie in the sky. Maybe with Surfblanks they are singing its praises in Oz and as Teccel in Brazil, and some other name in some other country. The Chinese might be singing the praises of Walker’s formula over there. **

**To sound a bit like Popeye: I have what I have and that’s what I have.
**

well its not my place to say what i  know or dont know.

 

 but how do you measure the end product when one formula is  created begining to end  in house

and then that formula is shiped across the planet  the main man is not there to oversea whats going on?

‘‘so that is the difference’’ surfblanks australia   should not be compared to s b america.   which by the way i doubt exist

sugar foam   nah no point.

 

oh did someone mention south africa?

link to more shenanigins

http://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/action/PJ … tid=157566

 

**cheers huie
**