Hey, Dr. S -
Before you order the UDTs, I would definitely find the right size to order them in. If, for instance, you’re using 3mm split-toe boots, you won’t find that 1mm fin socks are all that much thinner and your size doesn’t get appreciably smaller… leastwise mine didn’t.
For instance- I wear a ( US size) 8 1/2 to 9 extra wide shoe or work boot. With fin socks or up to 3mm boots, I wear a size large ( US sizes 9-11 ) and if I was gonna try it with 5-7mm dead of winter boots I might go up yet another size. Bear in mind that the new UDTs are a harder foot pocket/softer blade mix, not the ( rather silly, in my opinion) soft foot pocket and stiff blade mix that most other fins use, so you can get away with a foot pocket that’s a skosh on the long side.
The executive summary on that is don’t fall in love with a particular fin size, go for what fits with the boots you are gonna use. The regular Duck Feet are sized close enough to the UDTs that you can use what size works for one for the other as well.
The really thin, low type fin socks - well, here’s the thing with them: what they do is prevent your fins chafing the skin on your feet (especially the tops of your toes) but not a whole lot more. If you get the variety with the heel cutout, well, they are real nice if your surfing is done mostly from a boat but if you are crossing a sandy beach to the water you’re very, very likely to get a few grains of sand in there and the term ‘dermabrasion’ comes to mind in a big way. The ones I have do have a velcro bit that goes around the fin strap, so things stay together a little better.
For general use, what I like is a harder sole, split toe boot like you already have with ankle and boot-top Velcro, 3mm or so thick. It’s not like your feet are gonna be too hot and you can save a more worn-out pair with a few holes on the top for real warm water.
They will protect your feet some, the velcro at the ankle plus the split toe helps if you’re crossing sand or especially rock beaches: they don’t slip sideways or spin out on a slope and make you fall on your @ss on the cobblestones. And I am here to tell ya, that hurts.
You cannot make a 1mm boot that’s non-stretchy enough to give you decent hold on a sloping cobblestone beach. Like, say, rock climbing shoes, you want a tight-ish and positive fit, 'cos otherwise it’s busted @ss time, sooner or later.
Now, one more thing - get some honest to gawd fin tethers. They are cheap, they work well, more comfortable and ya don’t have to try tying them in the shorepound. The kind with a thick, padded, velcro closure ankle strap and a relatively light , about 3/8" wide nylon strap loop that goes around the fin strap has been good to me, you can put 'em on easy in the water, etc.
that help any? Be happy to answer any questions.
doc…